Could Your Next CEO Be a First-Timer?

Aged Care CEOs

There’s been plenty of movement at the top of Australia’s aged care sector.

By mid-October, The Weekly SOURCE had recorded 22 aged care CEO departures over the preceding 12 months. The announcements have continued, with both large operators and smaller, community-based providers experiencing changes in leadership.

Every departure creates an important decision for the organisation left behind. Who takes over? Where will the next CEO come from? And does the person stepping into the role need to have done the job before?

For experienced senior executives across aged care, this movement is also creating opportunities that may have seemed out of reach earlier in their careers. But taking the step from senior executive to CEO is a considerable transition, and the realities of the position can be very different depending on the organisation.

The same title, two very different jobs

Consider two CEOs working in aged care. One leads a small, community-based provider operating a single residential aged care home. The other oversees a national organisation with dozens of facilities, thousands of employees and an established executive team. Both carry the title of CEO. Both have significant responsibilities for the performance and direction of their organisations. But their working lives can look remarkably different.

At a smaller provider, the CEO may be involved in everything from cash flow and workforce issues to compliance, resident concerns and the organisation’s relationship with its local community. A CEO at a larger operator is likely to spend more time working through an executive team, managing strategic priorities, reporting to the board and overseeing performance across a complex portfolio.

Neither role is necessarily easier. They demand different experience, working styles and approaches to leadership. For someone considering their first CEO appointment, understanding those differences is important. The right opportunity may depend as much on the organisation as it does on the title.

The attraction of the first CEO role

For a senior executive who has spent years working towards the top job, the opportunity to become CEO can be an exciting prospect.

A Chief Operating Officer, Executive General Manager or senior operational leader may already have responsibility for substantial budgets, large teams and complex services. They may have played a significant role in improving financial performance, navigating regulatory changes or leading an organisation through difficult periods.

But stepping into the CEO position offers something different: responsibility for the direction and performance of the entire organisation. For ambitious professionals, that can be a compelling next step.

Smaller aged care providers can offer particularly interesting opportunities. With fewer layers of management, a CEO may be able to influence decisions more directly and see the results of their leadership across the organisation. They can also develop experience across areas of the business that may previously have sat outside their responsibilities.

For the right executive, a successful first CEO appointment can establish the foundation for a much longer career in senior leadership.

New aged care leadership

There’s a lot riding on that first appointment

Of course, becoming CEO brings pressures that can be difficult to appreciate until you’re in the role. The buck stops with you. Financial performance, workforce stability, resident outcomes, organisational culture and the relationship with the board all become part of the CEO’s responsibility.

In aged care, these pressures sit alongside significant regulatory obligations and ongoing scrutiny of how providers operate. An experienced operations executive may be highly capable in their own area of the business, but becoming CEO requires a broader perspective.

The transition can also be personally demanding. Decisions carry greater consequences, the relationship with the board changes and there may be fewer people within the organisation to turn to when difficult situations arise. It’s why a successful career as a senior executive doesn’t automatically guarantee success as a CEO.

Equally, having never held the position before doesn’t mean an individual lacks the capability to do it well.

Should boards take a chance on someone new?

For aged care boards, appointing a CEO is one of the most consequential decisions they make.

There is understandable reassurance in selecting someone with an established record in the top job, particularly when an organisation is facing financial difficulties, operational challenges or significant change. Previous CEO experience can bring valuable perspective and confidence. But boards that concentrate exclusively on candidates who have already held the title may overlook experienced leaders with considerable potential.

A senior executive who has successfully led complex operations may be ready for broader responsibility. Another candidate may bring experience from outside aged care that could be valuable to an organisation navigating growth or transformation.

The challenge is knowing which experience will translate into success in a particular CEO position. The needs of a single-site, community-based provider will differ from those of a large organisation managing multiple service types and locations. And the leader who is right for an organisation today may need different capabilities from the person who led it through its previous stage of development.

These are important distinctions when considering both established CEOs and executives hoping to take their first step into the role.

A changing leadership pipeline

Recent appointments also illustrate the different routes professionals can take into executive leadership.

In November, aged care and disability support platform Mable appointed Emma Clark as CEO, following her time as Chief Financial and Operations Officer with the business. Elsewhere, experienced aged care executives have moved into leadership positions in other industries, including former Regis Healthcare CEO Linda Mellors, who moved to InvoCare. These movements highlight the range of career paths available to senior leaders and the competition for experienced executive talent.

For aged care operators, succession will remain an important consideration as established leaders move on and organisations search for the people who will take them forward.

For professionals working below CEO level, there may be opportunities to take on greater responsibility sooner than they had anticipated.

And for those considering entering aged care from another industry, the experience they bring may be relevant to organisations seeking a different perspective.

Who will lead aged care next?

With experienced CEOs moving between organisations and industries, the next generation of aged care leaders deserves attention. Some will already be CEOs, bringing years of experience to their next appointment. Others will be accomplished senior executives ready to take on a broader role for the first time. There is no single career path to becoming an effective CEO, and the requirements of the job can vary considerably across the sector. What matters is finding the right person for the organisation, with the experience, judgement and capability to lead it through its next chapter.

At DCM Executive Recruitment, we work with aged care boards and operators to identify senior leadership talent, drawing on our understanding of the sector and the wider executive market.

We also speak confidentially with experienced executives about their career ambitions, including those exploring their first CEO appointment or considering a move to a larger organisation.

If you’re an operator planning a senior leadership appointment, or an executive considering your next career move, contact James Teodoro, Executive Director, DCM Executive Recruitment, for a confidential conversation.